There
are several criteria which are vitally important when choosing,
designing and working with a disc brake system:
(1) Keep deflection down;
(2) The use of hard linings to avoid flex from sponginess;
(3) The use of small diameter flex lines;
(4) The use of steel brake lines whenever possible;
(5) Volume requirements of the caliper;
(6) Available pedal ratio;
(7) Master Cylinder size and design.
There
are two types of calipers, floating or non floating.
Calipers
are generally made from three common casting metals: magnesium,
aluminium and cast iron. Calipers are made of different materials,
the most common are aluminium and cast iron.
The
material used in the calipers becomes important to help eliminate
deflection as deflection results in a spongy pedal.
The
modulus of elasticity is very important to eliminate the deflection
(flexing) of the caliper. The higher the modulus of elasticity
number, the greater resistance to flex. Magnesium has a modulus
of 6.5 million, aluminium has a modulus of 10 million, cast iron
has a modulus of 14.5 million and steel has a modulus of 30 million.
The
floating design was designed by the car manufacturers essentially
to make the calipers less expensive to produce. It successfully
applies the physics principle of "for every action caused
an opposite and equal reaction happens." With this in mind
they eliminated the piston(s) on one side of the caliper. This
floating caliper is not solidly mounted, but slides back and forth
on bushings.
When
braking force is applied, the piston pushes the brake pad on the
primary side and the reaction is the rotor being squeezed from
the force of the pad primary side allowing the horseshoe shaped
caliper to slide on the bushings so the secondary pads are used
to squeeze the rotor. The caliper has to be very rigid to retain
low deflection or the principle will be lost. Cast iron and steel
is used because of its' modulus number of 14.5 million and 30
million respectfully. This also increases the "sprung weight"
and it retains the heat longer. The big advantage to the full
floating design (single piston) is that if the rotor has a slight
run out (wobble), the floating feature will compensate without
creating any instability. The other advantage is the single piston
design is easier to bleed. The disadvantages are it is heavier,
retains heat, requires approximately 100 pounds of pressure more
to "slide" the caliper and requires more volume of brake
fluid due to the diameter of the piston. Floating designed calipers
also come with 2 pistons that are on the same side.
Non
floating calipers (ie. 2,4 or 6 piston) require a fixed mounting
bracket. Most race applications use this type of caliper, because
they are generally made of aluminium, which displaces the heat
faster and requires both less pressure and less volume to operate.
The floating design allows all the piston to be applied at the
same pressure, because the pressure is equalised when pressure
is applied, thereby allowing the rotor to be squeezed by opposing
forces (piston on each side). Aluminium will displace heat 1.5
to 3 times faster than the cast iron or steel calipers. This is
important when the rotors heat up to 1100 to 1200 degrees in a
racecar. Don't forget brake fluid has a boiling point of 550 to
700 degrees F. We have come a long way from the old 1965 Corvette
design calipers, current nonfloating calipers are easily rebuilt
and even have thermo barrier type pistons that reduced the transfer
of heat from the rotors.
OEM
(floating) vs 4 piston (non floating): Most of the brake kits
currently being sold are single piston OEM type calipers. In order
for the caliper to squeeze the rotor it has to use a floating
design, otherwise it would only apply pressure from one side to
the rotor. Because of this design you loose approximately 100
psi. 4 piston calipers squeeze from both sides and are fixed (don't
float), so they (4 piston) do not require as much pressure. The
single piston caliper also requires more volume to work. The area
of a 2 3/4" single piston caliper is 5.93 si VS the area
of two (2) pistons on a 4 piston design of 3.53 square inches.
(you only multiply by 2 piston to get the area because the other
2 pistons are being apply at the same time to squeeze the rotor,
unlike the one piston design) anyway 5.93' si VS 3.53 is a big
difference. Does the volume effect the braking? Yes, it has a
great effect on the master cylinder volume that is required for
ail 4 wheels. This will mean you will have to use a larger diameter
master cylinder to meet the requirements of the calipers. The
larger the master cylinder is the lower the pressure output.
Rotors
come in various designs, but basically there are vented rotors
and solid rotors. Rotors can be a one piece design with the hat
or hub incorporated in the casting or the two piece design where
the rotor is separate from the hat or hub. In this case the bigger
the rotor the better. The bigger the diameter means it takes that
much longer before the pad is in the same area during the rotation
of the rotor.
On
vented rotors the fins should be far enough apart to allow air
to flow between the fins, but close enough together so it allows
enough support for the rotor walls. There can be as much as six
tons of force being applied during braking and you do not want
any deflection. Some vented rotors have curved fins to allow better
flow of air and maximising the transfer of heat. Don't forget
these rotors can get up to 1,200 degrees F, so anything you can
do to assist the transfer of heat is a plus. If you have ever
watched a NASCAR short track race with the camera on the rotors,
you will know how hot they get.
Solid
rotors should never be used on a car weighing over 2,800 pounds.
These were designed for light duty and never used on a vehicie
where heavy braking is needed. These rotors serve a specific need
and work very good under limited conditions.
Your
better designed brake systems will have the rotor separate from
the hat or hub. This allows the rotor to have a uniform temperature
across the rotor (remember the NASCAR rotor?). By having this
uniformity it minimises the warping and cracking. Wilwood for
an example uses an aluminium hub in the front, which the rotors
bolt to. This allows the hot rotor to cool at the same rate throughout
the rotor, because it is made of different material and it is
a separate part. The aluminium hub is also designed to displace
heat and keep it away from the bearings (remember the modulus
of elasticity number is 75 percent that of cast iron, meaning
it will displace heat at a faster rate). Having a two piece design
also prevents the storage of this heat compared to a one piece
cast iron rotor. Calipers also benefit by having less heat transferred
to them and it assists to keep the brake fluid under the boiling
temperature.
Factories
use a one piece design, incorporating the hub/hat with the rotor;
this was done strictly for cost.
Notice
that the hub and rotor is cast as one piece. This does not allow
for the uniform distribution of heat and it is high prone to warping
and cracking due to the differences in temperature between the
rotor and hub area. The one piece cast iron rotor will also retain
heat longer, thereby transferring excessive heat to the calipers
and brake fluid. The only advantage to the one piece design is
initial cost. Did you really save any money?
|